Webster J. “Jay” Arceneaux handles litigation matters in a variety of
areas including: commercial, consumer, employment and labor, personal injury, including
toxic torts, and environmental. He also provides arbitration and mediation
services for parties in West Virginia and other States. Mr. Arceneaux has
received an AV rating from Martindale Hubbell; he is listed inBest Lawyers in
Americafor Litigation, Labor and Employment, and Mediation; he is listed inWest
Virginia Super Lawyers for Business Litigation, Employment and Labor and
Alternative Dispute Resolution; and he is a Fellow of the Litigation Counsel of
Mr. Arceneaux has represented parties in a variety of litigation matters in
state and federal court including:
- Defense of a chemical distributor of Perchlorethelene and Dibromomethane in a
class action medical monitoring case in the Circuit Court of Wyoming County and
before the Mass Litigation Panel in the Circuit Court of Raleigh County.
- Defense of law firms and financial institutions in claims alleging civil
penalties and common law damages for violations of the West Virginia Consumer Credit
and Protection Act.
- Defense of an employer in claims under the West Virginia Wage Payment and
Collection Act for unpaid commissions in United States District Court for the
Southern District of West Virginia.
- Prosecution of a bad faith and insurance coverage dispute and in the United
States District Court for the Southern District of West Virginia on behalf of
petroleum distribution company for failure to pay remediation expenses associated
with the clean up of a site for contamination related to underground storage
- Defense of employer in the Circuit Court of Monongalia County for sexual
harassment. That matter resulted in a decision by the Supreme Court of Appeals
of West Virginia decision affirming the Circuit Court of Monongalia County’ s
order that the sexual harassment case was required to be arbitrated inState ex
rel. Clites v. Clawges, 224 W.Va. 299, 685 S.E.2d 693 (2009). The case was
subsequently settled before the arbitration hearing.
- Representation of the Appellants before the Supreme Court of Appeals of West
Virginia in a minority shareholder dissent action under the prior code provisions of
W. Va. Code § 31-1-123 concerning the inadequate value of shares set by a
Special Commissioner and the Circuit Court of Berkeley County's improper ruling
regarding prejudgment interest. The Supreme Court of Appeals affirmed in
part and reversed in part inDodd. v. Potomac Riverside Farm, Inc.,222
W.Va. 299, 664 S.E.2d 184 (2008).
Mr. Arceneaux is trained by the American Arbitration Association as an arbitrator
and he is frequently sought out to handle the mediation and/or arbitration of complex
- Mediation of class action against employer for age discrimination resulting from
reduction in force.
- Mediation of numerous consumer cases alleging violations of the West Virginia
Consumer Credit and Protection Act.
- Arbitration under AAA of wrongful termination claim filed by employee against
national fast food restaurant chain.
- Arbitration under AAA of insurance coverage dispute arising from personal injury
at mine accident.
- Mediation of class action for improper drug testing against national retail chain
Mr. Arceneaux has been appointed to serve as a Special Commissioner for discovery
matters by the Honorable Jennifer Bailey Walker, Circuit Court of Kanawha County, West
Virginia, from July, 2002 to the present and he has also served as a Special
Commissioner for discovery matters for other Judges in the Circuit Courts of Kanawha
and Berkeley Counties, West Virginia. He was also appointed by the West Virginia Human
Rights Commission to serve as an Administrative Law Judge Pro Tempore in one case in
2007-09. A copy of the decision inSmith v. Montgomery General
Hospitalcan be found athttp://www.wvf.state.wv.us/wvhrc/2008-2009%20Decisions.htm
Mr. Arceneaux earned his undergraduate and law degrees from West Virginia University
in 1977 and 1980. He is admitted to practice before the West Virginia Supreme Court of
Appeals; the United States District Court, Southern and Northern Districts of West
Virginia; the U.S. Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit; the U.S. Court of Appeals, Sixth
Circuit; and the United States Supreme Court.
Mr. Arceneaux started his practice in 1980 as a Law Clerk to Justice Thomas Miller,
Supreme Court of Appeals of West Virginia. He also served from 1985 and 1986 as the
Deputy Attorney General, Environmental and Energy Division, State of West Virginia.
Mr. Arceneaux has handled numerous appellate matters before the Supreme Court of
Appeals of West Virginia, the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit and
he argued before the United States Supreme Court inBuckhannon Board and Care Home,
Inc., et al. v. West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources, et al., 532
U.S. 598 (2001).
Mr. Arceneaux is a recognized authority in West Virginia on mediation and
arbitration. He has taught continuing education seminars on the West Virginia
Consumer Credit and Protection Act, arbitration and mediation and he has trained
mediators throughout the State. Mr. Arceneaux devotes a substantial portion of
his time to arbitrating and mediating cases within West Virginia. He has mediated
and arbitrated consumer, employment, insurance and personal injury matters.
Mr. Arceneaux is the author of“Potential Criminal Liability in the Coal
Fields Under the Clean Water Act: A Defense Perspective, “ 95 West Virginia Law
Review 691 (1993).